On Empathy and Big Feelings

Zephaniah 1:7-18

On Empathy and Big Feelings (Zephaniah 1:7-18)
Matt Boswell

Zephaniah 1:7-9, 12-15, 18 (NRSV):

7 Be silent before the Lord God,
    for the day of the Lord is at hand!
The Lord has prepared a sacrifice;
    he has consecrated his guests.

8 And on the day of the Lord’s sacrifice
I will punish the officials and the king’s sons
    and all who dress themselves in foreign attire.

9 On that day I will punish
    all who leap over the threshold,
who fill their master’s house
    with violence and fraud.

12 At that time I will search Jerusalem with lamps,
    and I will punish the people
who settle like dregs in wine,
    those who say in their hearts,
“The Lord will not do good,
    nor will he do harm.”

13 Their wealth shall be plundered
    and their houses laid waste.
Though they build houses,
    they shall not inhabit them;
though they plant vineyards,
    they shall not drink wine from them.

14 The great day of the Lord is near,
    near and hastening fast;
the sound of the day of the Lord is bitter;
    the warrior cries aloud there.

15 That day will be a day of wrath,
    a day of distress and anguish,
a day of ruin and devastation,
    a day of darkness and gloom,
a day of clouds and thick darkness,

18 Neither their silver nor their gold
    will be able to save them
    on the day of the Lord’s wrath;
in the fire of his passion
    the whole earth shall be consumed,
for a full, a terrible end
    he will make of all the inhabitants of the earth.

Finally! Some good news for a change!

Is this good news? I suppose that depends on whether you’re—verse 7—the consecrated guest, set aside for safekeeping or to “help” with the work about to begin, or—verse 9—you’re a soon-to-be-punished “threshold-leaper.” How might we, a community centered on Love, respond to this text? Where is the Love?

Imagine, if you will, that you’re listening to someone who is going through something very difficult, where there is a clear person or group responsible for that person’s difficult situation. They share with you the distressing details of what they’re facing, and then, they point out how the person responsible for their pain seems to be experiencing no real consequences for their actions. They’re comfortable, they’re thriving, they even know the suffering they’ve caused your friend but are acting as if everything is fine because it’s in their best interest for everything to be…“fine.”

The distressed speaker starts breathing rapidly, their fists clench, and they say, about the one, or ones, responsible for their suffering: “I hope they lose everything!”

Now, it’s your turn to say something. Which of the following five options feels closest to the right thing to say, particularly in response to: “I hope they lose everything”?

  1. Well, now that’s not very nice!

  2. Hello, big feelings alert!

  3. Have you prayed for God to give you a gracious heart?

  4. Did you see the game last night? The defense was atrocious!

  5. That must be so, so difficult.

Knowing you all, your response would be—empathy. And so you wouldn’t choose option one, a scolding, which focuses on the wrong thing. You wouldn’t choose option two, mockery, likely arising from your own discomfort with emotions. You wouldn’t choose option three, which, while yes, we can often only control our own response, not other’s actions, sounds like it locates the problem in the attitude of the harmed, not the actions of the harm-causer. You wouldn’t choose option four, avoidance, changing the subject to something that feels easier. You would probably choose something close to my fifth option, the most caring and validating response, even if imperfect. And you might even offer a bold addendum, if you had the space for it: “what can I do to help?”

For those of us who’ve experienced the weaponization of scriptures that speak to God’s anger as a way of manipulating “sinners” into compliance and submission, we might be inclined to say “don’t need this part of the Bible; that’s not the God we know.” But I think a third way, beyond a literalist, unquestioning reading, or tearing out the pages you find problematic, is to read the Bible with empathy. Much like you’d listen to a friend, with empathy.

With a struggling friend, you might try to: grasp the intensity of and rationale behind their feelings; not rush them through their grief; listen to their painful truth without correcting them or tone policing them—even if they say some pretty harsh things about their harm-causers. Just because you believe there is that of God in every person, doesn’t mean people don’t do horrible things that should be named for what they are.

Can anger awaken people to life-saving action? Or is it just a distracting emotion to be set aside in favor of something calmer, more composed, more balanced?

Many Friends have suggested we read the Bible with empathy. To me, that means we don’t treat every verse as a binding, universally-applicable dictate that tells us what to think or do, or how to feel. It means trying to understand what’s at stake for those represented, recognizing and feeling their pain with them, and the wishes that arise out of that pain, whether for vengeance, for liberation, or for relief.  When we empathize, we may discover where people are coming from and what they need that they aren’t getting. We may even learn something about ourselves.

Some of you have noticed the “war on empathy,” instigated by some on the Christian right. At the core, I think they believe empathy undermines control. When you empathize, you are vulnerable in a way that means relinquishing control. You open yourself to ways of understanding that may contradict the established tradition and its gatekeepers. Empathy also disrupts those who would control you. With empathy you may come to recognize that the condemnation espoused by your faith tradition toward certain people isn’t fair, and then you question the tradition, which could undermine a controlling system, scaring those who think they need to control or be controlled.

I would humbly suggest that a Biblical text like this deserves neither our uncritical acceptance or our full condemnation. Can we instead, with empathy, ask questions like: “what reality gave rise to such words, such big feelings, such anger? What valid hopes are revealed?” If we do that, we might find that even if we aren’t 100% on board with this, or wish we’d been allowed to wordsmith this speech more before releasing into the public domain, that we can appreciate the challenges and pains voiced here.

Zephaniah writes before what you might call a real-life apocalyptic-level event for this ancient community: the destruction of the temple in Jerusalem and beginning of a half-century exile in Babylon. The prophet may be noticing some troubling patterns and trying to warn this community, particularly its government and wealthy, before things get to the point of total national catastrophe. Or maybe he is rightly anticipating what is coming, through the poetic language of God’s judgment, even if humans are the ones responsible. The ancient Hebrew prophets recognize the role conquering Empires play, historically speaking, but tend to frame such catastrophes as acts of Divine judgment.

This scripture speaks to a kind of judgment day. “The Day of the Lord.” Terrifying? Or worth celebrating? I guess it depends. Judgment day might sound scary, if you’re worried that you are going to be punished or tormented.

But it may not be totally fair to think of “judgment” as either simply a punishment or like the way we use the word “judgmental,” by which I think people usually mean: unfairly criticizing others from a place of superiority, as if they’re only bad and you’re only good. A judgment can also be an appraisal, made by someone who is qualified to make such an appraisal, who has weighed the evidence and is ready and willing to simply name what’s there.

What if I said to my kid, “ok, I’m ready to make a judgment: when there are two cookies, and you take two and leave none for your little brother, that’s not so great for your little bro, is it? So how are we going to fix this?” Is that a cruel judgment? Quite the contrary, I’d say! While it might be painful to the older sibling to relinquish one cookie, if not more, as an act of repair, this judgment is…relief, to little bro, right? Judgment may often be an expression of the Love that is making all things new.

Is Love ever destructive? It might depend on what’s being destroyed. What if we’re destroying patriarchy and sexism? Or systemic racism and colonization? What if we’re destroying Christian nationalism? What if we’re destroying ego or self-centeredness or personal addiction? Or fossil fuel addiction?

An angry God might be jolting, and that’s valid. But might there not be some relief in a God who cares about harm being caused and wants to do something about it? Given the toxic and abusive ways anger shows up in our world, in certain individuals, it might be hard to not assume this God is just a projection of the worst impulses of humanity.

So, instead, think of those who’ve revealed and directed their anger to wake people up to injustice. When human suffering is present and human lives are at stake, is anger a moral failure or a sign of engagement with reality? It could be either, but I think the latter applies here. Does God punish people for being part of the wrong religion, or being imperfect, or making poor choices under immense pressure? I don’t think so. Does God actually care about our suffering? The resounding answer of this text is: YES. 

Or, consider those who might read this from the margins. How would enslaved peoples receive this if their lens led them to see God targeting their enslavers? Or indigenous people, if they read this as a critique of white colonizers? Or, the disabled community, if they read this as a critique of those not willing to make accommodations?

I would also note that it’s not really fair to draw a contrast between Old Testament and New Testament Gods as “angry God vs gracious God”; this overlooks the Divine calls for justice and compassion in the Hebrew Bible, it overlooks the continuity between Jesus and his tradition, and it’s also dangerously anti-Jewish. The Day of the Lord might be the relief of life-saving change, or at least the spark of such change. We don’t need to wish for the death of every oppressor to empathize with the hopes of the oppressed.

Listen to the words of this text, again, through my paraphrase, and listen with empathy, like you’re listening to someone who needs you to hear the intensity of their pain.

“Hey everybody, stop what you are doing and be silent, the day has come, we’ll finally be able to exhale and find peace. We have been consecrated, set aside for safekeeping.

But God has prepared a sacrifice: the officials. The king’s sons. The wealthy who dress in fancy foreign clothes. All who leap over the threshold, breaking into your home, so to speak, and taking what is yours. All who commit violence against you. All the frauds, those who cheat the system and take advantage of others. They are so toast! (7-9)

“And don’t worry, God will be thorough, so that what is hidden will be drawn into the light and laid bare. All who would say “God doesn’t care about whether we exploit the poor or the Earth’s resources, God just cares about souls, spiritual stuff that has nothing to do with our common life together!” Those people? Toast. The wealth that gives the wealthy a buffer others lack? Toast. Their mansions with excessive square footage while we have no roof over our heads? Toast. Oh they’ll keep building houses, but for us to inhabit. We will have the shelter we have so desperately lacked. They’ll plant vineyards, but to provide nourishment for all, not just the few. (12-13)

“The Day of the Lord! It’s really happening! And it will be bitter for those who’ve lived so comfortably and with indifference to the plight of the masses! It will be anguish. Ruin. Devastation. Gloom. But thank God for the darkness this is our deliverance, the dark clouds that are relief from the scorching sun, the darkness of recreation, of incubation, of something new being born. The darkness that is our salvation. (14-15)

“Oh, and they won’t be able to buy their way out of this judgment. God, whose Love is tender and compassionate yet passionate and fierce, like a mama bear protecting her young, will decisively act. In fact, the whole Earth is in the scope of this judgment: there is no place our oppressors can hide. This terrible end is coming in ways that impacts every inhabitant of the earth. Divine Love will be thorough.” (18)

Might not be the best paraphrase, but does that at least somewhat capture the painful reality that gives rise to the prophet’s words? And do note my interpretation of that last verse. I don’t think Zephaniah, or God, has suddenly lost their cool and now—turns out—we’re all toast, not just the ones who perpetrate injustice. I think this is a complete end, not a universal one, if that makes sense. The hope is that all injustice will be addressed, all evil uprooted, and what is good and beautiful will endure, in safety, in peace, in joy. That doesn’t mean that everything needs to go, but that Divine Love will be thorough. What does that mean for our Love? 

Now if that’s just wishful thinking on my part, and we’re seeing Zephaniah and the community he represents, up the stakes from “let’s repair what’s broken!” to just, “to hell with the whole thing, let’s start over,” then remember my encouragement: that we not literalize, but empathize, and make space for the feelings voiced here; and that we consider the possibility that judgment could mean relief and new beginnings. 

Devastation can bring new life. When greed is judged and falls, maybe generosity rises. When white patriarchy is judged and falls, maybe an inclusive and dynamic community comes to be. When your exaggerated sense of self-importance is judged and falls, maybe better ways of being in relationship with others emerge. In the good and holy darkness of Divine judgment, where cruelty and harm are named and dealt with thoroughly, the people breathe sigh of relief, new life is born, new possibilities arise.

So like I said: “Finally! Some good news for a change!”

Queries:

What is my response to Zephaniah’s prophetic words?

What difference does empathy make?

When might Love encourage us to make judgments?

How do we end and move beyond tyranny? What’s on the other side?

How can we treat every person as sacred and oppose what is evil?


First Word: Cat Willett

First Word
Cat Willett
Next
Next

The Journey of Living Things (Guest Speaker: Justin Gentry)